Hail the Big Head Carp

Anglers can only sigh at them.

As they make their graceful, sure and steady rises on the surface of ponds, lakes and rivers, anglers can only sigh longingly. Because cast as we might and bait as we will, our chances of getting them on rod and line are only a little better than winning the jackpot.

The bighead carp - Aristichthys nobilis - is easily recognisable because of its disproportionately large head, its incredibly large and thick mouth and its low-set eyes. Many would call it ugly. In Malaysian dining, the fish is generally known as “tai tau pok” or “soong yee”. However, it is not a popular eating fish as it is bony and its flesh tends to carry a pungent, muddy taste.

It has a tremendous growth rate and record sizes easily exceed the 50kg mark. In the Missouri River, the United States, it is reported that thousands of tons of bighead carps can be caught in area of less than half an acre on the river. Though it is not native to Malaysian freshwater, it has firmly entrenched its position as a part of the Malaysian freshwater fish population for well over a century.

The reason anglers seldom obtain the privilege of catching one of these impressive fish is because it is primarily a zooplankton and phytoplankton feeder almost throughout its lifespan. The fish swims up and down with its big mouth wide open nearly 24 hours a day, feeding on tonnes of plankton at various depths. In the process, it also consumes detritus, algae and bacteria.

A large population of bighead carps in an ex-mining lake is able to reduce the planktonic life of a lake so effectively as to render the lake’s water gin clear. By reducing microbiological life in the water, dissolved oxygen becomes more available to fish. The general fish population is also less prone to attacks by fungus and bacteria. Sunlight penetrates the clearer water more deeply, allowing for better ultraviolet light exposure that will further improve the quality of the water.

For many decades, eventhough bighead carps don’t fetch a good price in the market, freshwater fish farmers have learnt to include a goodly population of bighead carps in their fish ponds to control algae and other microbiological growth, thus lending to a better yield of the main fishes in their ponds.

In duck farms, bighead carps are important fishes in the duck ponds as they keep detritus and planktonic life in check. Duck pond waters are very high in nutrients, thanks to the ducks. Left to its own designs, the planktonic and microbiological life will explode to such a degree as to cause grave danger to the ducks. As such, most duck ponds in Perak (where duck farming is popular in ex-mining lakes) boast amazingly clear water in spite of years of duck breeding.

This fish, therefore, is a good microbiological control agent to introduce into our lakes and river systems.

Many lakes and ponds in housing estates, though pleasing to the eye, are actually harbours of pathogenic problems. Urban water features are inevitably high in nutrients that will breed a wide range of planktonic and microbial life, and some of them will threaten human well-being. Unsuspecting anglers fishing an urban pond may come into contact with the water carrying dangerous microbes. At the end of their angling session, they go home and bring the microbial problem with them.

I think the authorities should conduct a thorough study into putting this fish into our urban freshwater features. The fries are easily obtained though fish farms.

The flip side of this suggestion is that since the bighead carp can grow so impressively, they have no natural predators. Since they so rarely take a baited hook, they cannot even be naturally culled by angling. Therefore, they can grow to such size and numbers that they will eventually become a problem themselves by robbing other fishes of living and breeding space. It is thus necessary to cull them with nets when the situation arises. Although they don’t make good eating fish, it is good to remember that the fish effectively centres thousands of tonnes of otherwise useless biomass in the form of microbes and plankton and detritus into themselves. Humans may not like to eat them. But livestock will not mind. So it is highly possible that these bighead carps can be cooked and prepared as a valuable protein supplement for a large variety of other livestock. In addition, their protein content can be processed with special microbes and be converted into a high grade nitrogenous fertilizer for horticultural applications.

However, the above suggestion does not factor in the high probability that urban ponds contain unhealthy levels of heavy metals, which will pollute the big head carps and thus compromise their eligibility to provide proteinaceous supplements or nitrogenous fertilizer.

I wonder if there are actually scientists reading this discussion group, and urge them to take a closer look at turning organic freshwater pollution into an opportunity using this fish.

Murphy’s Three-fold Law:

  1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.

  2. Everything will take longer than you think it should.

  3. If anything can possibly go wrong, it will.

Lord of the morning,

A very nice writeup and very informative. I had caught few big head carp using bait. Eaten fish head (big carp, off course!!) noodle. The muddy taste is “sticky” very strong.. May I ask what is the slime substance that cover its body & it is safe to touch it since it devour viruses & bacteria?

Enjoy the fishing process… even I get NIL at the end.

Good and informative writeup. Ques: If this fish is bacteria eating, the flesh safe for consumption?

* Team Spinboyz - U1 2004 * Team MalPro - U2 2004 * Team Lucky Craft Happy Hookers - U3 2005 * Marshall - U4 2006 * General Worker - U5 2007 * U6 2008 - Watch out it’s gonna get tougher because you guys are getting better!</font id=“size1”>

“We (MFN forumers) are a few but together we are many. We are many among the millions of anglers yet to have their voices heard” - Majulah sukan memancing untuk negara

wow if it only eats bacteria and algae, it will take a long time to fill the stomach! Do you think it can be caught on fly using nymph or something similar?

Before we go oo la la with this fish (especially with malaysia record of screwing things up, all with good intentions of course![xx(]), perhaps we should consider what is the exit strategy should this thing go wrong. An effective and do able exit strategy, not just talking about strategy.

Here’s a link or two, just to keep everything in perspective before doing anything rash:
LInk 1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yS7zkTnQVaM

Continued in
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ChwJiKKBdA&feature=related

[img=left]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/PAW%20Logo/pawsign.gif[/img=left]

Well, first of all, good write up and very informative indeed LOTM bro… this is quite surprising and interesting

Although it’s a good idea considering the theory, but we’ve made too much mistake in the past to not learn any of them the hard way. Just like the PB epidemic, it started with good cause and intention, but nobody would have imagined how disastrous things went… This is just an example, there’re much more such as leekoh, tilapia, luohan(darn this critters) etc… Non-fish species too like the red-ear turtles

IMHO, there’s a lot more alternative than this, just that we havent find the clue to solve this intriguing puzzle. While i totally agree this is a good measure to weed out all the harmful biomass and bacteria, i absolutely do not support tempering with nature(play-God). Nature have evolve the way it is today from eons ago have it’s own perfection to say the least, why disturb it?

Besides, i would also like to recommend any local species that might very well do the job for their ‘alien’ ccounterpart, pls consider fish like lomah which is wholly native… They have the same characteristic, traits and share a lot of similarity except for the size ofcourse. They thrive in dams in big numbers, could it be the case that most dam are so clear and clean? Other than that, they are not known to take baited hooks, could it be plankton and bacteria that they’re after(can’t use plankton as bait)? What about many more native species out there, waiting for their potential to be unveiled?

I may be young and a greenhorn to all sifus here. But i would like to share my view on this interesting topic. And hopefully readers would not ignore my 2 cent worth of opinion. I wrote this in goodwill and in no way condemning anyone so if there’s any misunderstanding and discomfort i hereby apologise, and i’ll be more than willing to get any correction from any kind readers. Lastly, thank you for payin heed to this tiny voice.

I only have 10 years of fishing experience, so must beri tunjuk ajar!

Mr. Tan, your voice is not a tiny voice or 2 cents worth.. Everyone has his own opinion and thought. Sometimes we are have to find the right solution in view of nature, economic, finance, resources to certain demand. Anyway & anyhow each and every decision we make will have the good & bad effects. My humble question is what can we as an angler do to protect the natives species? Kelah, Sebarau, Tapah, Temoleh, Belida & etc are fast dissapering due to encroachment of their natural habitat, over fishing and many other causes that many Malaysian will know in their heart. The immigrant fish is cheaper & grow much more faster, it become a cheap food source for many immigrant as well local malaysian.

Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

Good points there TJS. True, there are many herbivorous and plankton eaters in our water that can be a good candidates.

It’s not the intention of ‘playing god’ when it’s the habitat to be healed. It’s the human factor in the first place that polluted the ponds with so many inputs. AND it’s our responsibility to make sure that we ‘clean up’ the mess appropriately.

If local species can do that; even better BUT we can’t deny the important of introduce species if used correctly.

[IMG]
http://longkanggang.blogspot.com

U3-Team Orang Kampong
U4-Team Longkang (1st runner up)
MFN 07 Billfish Series (2nd,Group Categories)
U5-LKG Ribena Boys (2nd Runner up)
MFN 08 Billfish Challenge (Champion Team)

So what can we do for the excessive big head carp? Consume it? Is it safe for human consumption?

Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

Most of huge fishes bioaccumulate toxin from various sources. Better to avoid them.

[IMG]
http://longkanggang.blogspot.com

U3-Team Orang Kampong
U4-Team Longkang (1st runner up)
MFN 07 Billfish Series (2nd,Group Categories)
U5-LKG Ribena Boys (2nd Runner up)
MFN 08 Billfish Challenge (Champion Team)

Sild bro, how about the slime that cover the big head carp? very thick & sticky like eel at seaside..? I guess better to have less contact & thoroughly wash my hand & fishing gear as well.

quote:
Originally posted by Sild
Most of huge fishes bioaccumulate toxin from various sources. Better to avoid them.

[IMG]
http://longkanggang.blogspot.com

U3-Team Orang Kampong
U4-Team Longkang (1st runner up)
MFN 07 Billfish Series (2nd,Group Categories)
U5-LKG Ribena Boys (2nd Runner up)
MFN 08 Billfish Challenge (Champion Team)


Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

kucai,

Holy Jumping Jacks! So it really is true. When I read that silver carps will leap at passing boats, I thought it was a rare occurrence! Forget bowfishing! It will take an HK-MP5-SD6 sub machine gun to knock them all out.

Imagine a 10kg carp flying through the air towards us. The impact must hurt.

The silver carp looks exactly like the big head carp, except that it is bright silver in colour. Thankfully, there aren’t any silver carps in Malaysia.

Anyway, I was moved to express my thoughts on the big head carp via an observation of a very large ex-mining lake that I fish regularly in Temoh, Perak.

The water really is gin-clear.

One morning while fishing for default peacock bass, I observed a fisherman paddling along the long length of a net that he had placed right across the lake for a few days. In the distance, i could see him struggling with very large fish. As he came back to the bank, I couldn’t resist myself and went to him.

He was struggling to bring in seven extremely large big head carps. I think each fish weighed between 10 and 20 kgs EACH. Have you ever see a little sampan carrying a fisherman and seven fishes weighing between 70 and 140kg, not including the fisherman? Try to imagine it and you can get a feel of how amazed I felt. Too bad I didn’t take a photo. The fisherman was positively breathless. But he had enough in him to let me know that he sells them to a local restaurant for RM1 per kg. And he nets the lake once every few months. Eventually, the carps wise up to his net, and he will only catch one or none a day. Then he removes his net and moves on the the next lake.

A. The lake’s water is so clear that you can see fish swimming near the bank up to about 5ft deep. And i m quite sure this is due to the big head carps’ act of gobbling up all that plankton, algae and whatchamacallit in the water. Once, I watched about 20 small to medium peacock bass following at the back of my lure towards me. What a sight!

B. All the default peacock bass and the RARE haruan that I catch from this lake are beautiful. The colours, vibrant. The fins, very healthy, never any sign of water fleas or fungal attacks or whatever.

As the fisherman threw the big head carps into his van, I gave them a silent word of thanks for cleaning up the lake and wished them their very best in the next lives. Locals told me that 10 years ago, the lake used to hold a large duck farm. The water was a green soup of algae and god knows what else, and water hyacinth had carpeted the lake almost completely. The water hyacinth is cleared now, cos the Perak state government wants to use the lake for dragon boat racing competitions. And the water, well, hail the big head carp!

Not to worry though. There are still lots of big head carps breaking the water surface as the fisherman drove away.

I didn’t make a scientific observation nor did I make a scientific opinion. I observed and was warmed by the quality of this lake as an angler, as a consumer and user of the lake. And it inspired me to believe that the big head carps can do the same for urban lakes too. Don’t you think that if all that green soup in the Lake Gardens and Titiwangsa were cleared up, the lakes would look a lot more attractive, and maybe even safer? It is up to scientists to make use of empirical experiences such as mine to create something and think out an exit strategy once the big head carps become a problem in themselves. To quote Whitney Houston (of all people. in a fishing forum!): “Nothing is so good, it lasts eternally. Perfect situations must go wrong…”

Alien species? Please la. Sometimes, I miss Ron Looi!!! He got so badly flamed and bombed by us over his peacock bass stand about 5 years ago that we no longer see him here now. We hated him and how much he believed that the peacock bass will be good for malaysian angling.

And now, I so very often see pictures of smiling anglers holding PBs. Why don’t we take photos of the PBs we catch with a hateful grimace just to justify all the things we had said to Ron?

Are there other fishes to do the job? Well, suggest away. Not the lomah though. They need too much oxygen, and I don’t think their system is robust enough to handle heavy metals.

Murphy’s Three-fold Law:

  1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.

  2. Everything will take longer than you think it should.

  3. If anything can possibly go wrong, it will.

So I summarize it as :

Big Head Carp : Good for contaminated pond but it grows rapidly.

Is this a silver carp? At Kolam Joran Setia (Undertaker), Melaka.

Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

Apek Cina;

That’s the Big Head Carp.

LOTM;
We used to have that silver carp (Kap Perak) in our lake; not sure about the status now.

[IMG]
http://longkanggang.blogspot.com

U3-Team Orang Kampong
U4-Team Longkang (1st runner up)
MFN 07 Billfish Series (2nd,Group Categories)
U5-LKG Ribena Boys (2nd Runner up)
MFN 08 Billfish Challenge (Champion Team)

Thanks Sild, for the info, I thought it was silver carp due to its body color..

Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

Apek,

Sh!+

I think that’s the silver carp, sild. So from now on, we have to wear full face helmets, body armour and ball guards while on the boat. hahahaha

Murphy’s Three-fold Law:

  1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.

  2. Everything will take longer than you think it should.

  3. If anything can possibly go wrong, it will.

quote:
Originally posted by Lord of the Morning
Apek,

Sh!+

I think that’s the silver carp, sild. So from now on, we have to wear full face helmets, body armour and ball guards while on the boat. hahahaha

Murphy’s Three-fold Law:

  1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.

  2. Everything will take longer than you think it should.

  3. If anything can possibly go wrong, it will.


Wow.. Lucky then, it is in Melaka… phew.. kena tampar kang, mampus aku.. pengsan..dehhhhhh.. Better avoid this pond.. issue ISA.. Hahaha

Enjoy the fishing process… even I pulang tangan kosong…

I think the silver carp is somewhat if not our grass carp. They can be plentiful in some old mining ponds that were used for fish rearing ponds.

These types of fishes, to my opinion had not yet been an ecological problem. In the old days it was a popular eating fish and some older Chinese still love them. I am personally partial to ginger steamed tail section of a grass carp and claypot braised fishead of the bighead carp.

At my local pasar malam, these carps are also very popular with many foreign workers due to its price. most of the time the bighead carps minus the head is sold for less than RM8/kg. making it a cheap source for protein.

I just the claypot braised fish head of big head carp sold at Shah Alam… nice & delicious..

But hooking up one if entirely different story.. the smell..yuksssssssssss

Enjoy the fishing process… including fish borrowed for photoshot…

quote:
Originally posted by Lord of the Morning
kucai,

Alien species? Please la. Sometimes, I miss Ron Looi!!! He got so badly flamed and bombed by us over his peacock bass stand about 5 years ago that we no longer see him here now. We hated him and how much he believed that the peacock bass will be good for malaysian angling.

And now, I so very often see pictures of smiling anglers holding PBs. Why don’t we take photos of the PBs we catch with a hateful grimace just to justify all the things we had said to Ron?

Murphy’s Three-fold Law:

  1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.

  2. Everything will take longer than you think it should.

  3. If anything can possibly go wrong, it will.


Halo’ LOTM,

Long time no see. Hope alls well. Your mention of Ron Looi brought on a smile.[:)] I guess just as there are good and bad anglers, there are also those who care and those who don’t care about the ecology. They just want to catch a fish.[:D][xx(] Cheers.

<><ICHTUS><>