Netting in our water

Bro Oakinn, yes I agree, we cannot wait for the authorities and we can do something like sink some unused vietnamese trawlers, throw used tires, etc and creating safe havens for the fish, free from the trawlers. In fact, a few weeks ago, while discussing this topic with my fishing buddy NBK, we are thinking of just doing that on our own.

I also have a copy of the Nat Geo magazine with me. Its so disheartening to read it. Must get into action.

Maybe we can organize a program and get anglers to participate in creating artificial reefs in our local areas. We can cooperate with the local inshore fisherman also, as it will benefit them too.

Check this out on the successes of creating marine reserves,
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2001/12/1204_TVmarinereserves.html

Funny that PeMM, a fishing/angling association, should be blame for not doing anything on some Fisheries Dept. boat netting in our water.

What do we expect PeMM to do other than signature campaign to put pressure on relevant authority and creating public awareness ?

Should PeMM publish all complain letter forwarded to relevant authority in their website for all to view.

Is there any regulations for creating artifical reef and why has Fishery Dept. never think of that ?

Is there any other method we can follow/emulate to prevent trawlers from encroaching into shallow water and reducing by-catch ?

good question ikanbilis bro…any possible answer to the question bro?

[img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/Picture4.jpg[/img] [img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/PAW%20Logo/pawsign.gif[/img] OAKINN PAW Board of Director & Abu Svangsta Gangsta 2005 Tel/Fax: 09-5178004/012-9989959 http://pahanganglersworld.blogspot.com/
quote:
Funny that PeMM, a fishing/angling association, should be blame for not doing anything on some Fisheries Dept. boat netting in our water.

What do we expect PeMM to do other than signature campaign to put pressure on relevant authority and creating public awareness ?

Should PeMM publish all complain letter forwarded to relevant authority in their website for all to view.

Is there any regulations for creating artifical reef and why has Fishery Dept. never think of that ?

Is there any other method we can follow/emulate to prevent trawlers from encroaching into shallow water and reducing by-catch ?


</font id=“quote”></blockquote id=“quote”>

The creation of artificial reefs though commendable must be researched as well. Best to have it done with the authorities involved. If not, fingers would be pointed all directions when some mishap happens.

Scenario 1 : The boats confiscated by the authorities may have cases pending. They are therefore evidence waiting for presentation at the respective courts when the cases come up for mention. If we remove the boats to make reefs without the OK from the authorities, we are commiting a crime ourselves!

Scenario 2 : We find a perfect place to dump our Tukun of rubber tyres tied together. Sometime down the line, the local nelayan’s anchor or nets gets caught in our tukun. Complaints to LKIM(whose in charge of the livelihood of the fishermen).LKIM comes down on us for unauthorised construction of the tukun.

Dont forget that the Malaysian authorities are infamous for passing the buck a pointing fingers!

As much as I hate it, we have to work with the authorities on this. Unfortunately, they have the final say on the matter.
We are currently trying to work with them on the viability of affordable tukuns and how to prevent the trawlers from entering such areas which should remain exclusive to the coastal fishermen and anglers.

RainbowRunner

Tightlines and screaming reels

RR, I was told that this tukun thingy is a big business & there are many tukun tycoons who are linked with the right people. I reckon that since they are businessman who does work with their networked individual, they should logically lobby for tukun within a geographical area that is controlled by their networked individual, so the tukun maynot necessarily be in the right place afterall…but this reasoning is based on my crooked negative side of my brain lah..he.he.he..hope its not all true.

I proposed that we get Perikanan to designate/approve a site for the artificial reef, they can invest in the basic tkun infrastructure, according to whatever budget they can get, say…planting those 3-thumb reef thingy on 4 corner spots so that the trawlers cannot get into the inner zone, we then rally the public & collect money to invest in a few more smaller unjams or artificial reef within the inner zone. Building of this innerzone can be an ongoing project for PeMM & the local guys so that after a few years we will have a monster-trawler free zone, a place where shore fisherman can feed their families & sport anglers to wet their line…haaa, itu macam…whay say U…anyhow, your small friend here are lobbying this, albeit on a very very very minute scale…only PeMM can do this big time…my sweat is yours, I just need PeMM’s brain & turbo engine…ada kaa?

[img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/Picture4.jpg[/img] [img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/PAW%20Logo/pawsign.gif[/img] OAKINN PAW Board of Director & Abu Svangsta Gangsta 2005 Tel/Fax: 09-5178004/012-9989959 http://pahanganglersworld.blogspot.com/

Sorry Oakinn,

I have no answer to all the questions I posted earlier.
Just that I have been following this topic and the debate somehow raises all the questions.

I’m new in this forum as well as in angling, but I’m think that:

a. PeMM would have no authority to do anything to anyone breaking the law except to provide proof to relevent authority

b. What else can PeMM or any other association/NGO/individual do other than raising public awreness and signature campaign

c. Its just a suggestion that PeMM should publish complain letter forwarded to relevant authority in relation to conservation and preservation issue

d. I have just read about Rainbowrunner’s answer re artificual reef, thanks

quote:
RR, I was told that this tukun thingy is a big business & there are many tukun tycoons who are linked with the right people. I reckon that since they are businessman who does work with their networked individual, they should logically lobby for tukun within a geographical area that is controlled by their networked individual, so the tukun maynot necessarily be in the right place afterall...but this reasoning is based on my crooked negative side of my brain lah..he.he.he..hope its not all true.

I proposed that we get Perikanan to designate/approve a site for the artificial reef, they can invest in the basic tkun infrastructure, according to whatever budget they can get, say…planting those 3-thumb reef thingy on 4 corner spots so that the trawlers cannot get into the inner zone, we then rally the public & collect money to invest in a few more smaller unjams or artificial reef within the inner zone. Building of this innerzone can be an ongoing project for PeMM & the local guys so that after a few years we will have a monster-trawler free zone, a place where shore fisherman can feed their families & sport anglers to wet their line…haaa, itu macam…whay say U…anyhow, your small friend here are lobbying this, albeit on a very very very minute scale…only PeMM can do this big time…my sweat is yours, I just need PeMM’s brain & turbo engine…ada kaa?</font id=“red”>


Oakin,

Correct me if I am wrong but I think it is Perikanan or LKIM that tenders the tukun project out. The tukun tycoons then sends in their tenders for the job.
As far as I know, Perikanan does not have such things like barges for transportation, cranes for lifting, etc. It’s all in the tenders. They may be the authorities on the matter but they depend solely on the tukun tycoons.

Perikanan or LKIM picks the spot and the contractor does the rest. However, their tender/contract does not cover maintenance so the tukun is as good as not contructed at all.

To be precise, what we need here is some device that protects the inshore areas. We are currently working on something with the Pahang state govt. but cannot divulge any further info. at this moment.
If all goes well, it would set a precedence to have it implemented in all states.
You know full well how slow the wheels of bureaucracy turns but we are optimistic about it.

RainbowRunner

Tightlines and screaming reels</font id=“size3”>

oooo, great news for Pahang, hope the slow wheel of beuracracy can be oiled so they move faster…he.he.he.

[img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/Picture4.jpg[/img] [img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y82/oakinn/PAW%20Logo/pawsign.gif[/img] OAKINN PAW Board of Director & Abu Svangsta Gangsta 2005 Tel/Fax: 09-5178004/012-9989959 http://pahanganglersworld.blogspot.com/

So do I, bro but sometimes other factors come into play beyond our control. Still, we remain optimistic![:D]
We must not forget that the Pahang state govt. is state admin but Perikanan is federal admin![;)]

RainbowRunner

Tightlines and screaming reels

Depletion of fish source has made headlines. Article below taken from The Sunday Star dated 3 June 2007. Time for even anglers to monitor own take.

Fishermen blame pollution for depleting fish population

By LOONG MENG YEE, EDDIE CHUA and NIK KHUSAIRI IBRAHIM

KUALA SELANGOR: Fisherman Koh Har Tiong loved the sea for various reasons – the fresh breeze and its vastness. He also loved it for the bountiful fish it provided.

That was 10 years ago.

Now, he is thankful if he can get 10 barrels of fish each time he goes out to sea, a far cry from the 30 barrels he used to haul in then.

And the blue seawater has now turned murky, grey, smelly and lifeless.

Not only is there less fish to catch, even the fish in his net are smaller.

He blames pollution and the cutting down of mangrove trees as the reasons why the number of fish in the sea is getting smaller.

“My house is just beside the river. A decade ago, the water was so clear we could see the bottom.

“There were many fishes, crabs and prawns. We could catch them with our eyes closed,” Koh, from Kampung Sasaran here, said.

Koh, 31, and his fellow villagers have watched the river die. They claim that upstream factories released effluents into the river while the mangroves along the banks of the river were chopped down.

Rubbish started to float around as irresponsible people used the sea as a convenient dumping ground.

“The chemicals polluted the sea and destroyed the seabed. When you damage the mangroves and the seabed, you kill the fish because they have no place to lay their eggs and find food,” said Koh.

Local freshwater and marine fish expert Prof Mohd Azmi Ambak said that in the last 50 years, some 20 species of freshwater fish had become extinct.

Local fishermen, he said, were finding it hard to catch once common and abundant species such as the red and golden snapper.

“Freshwater species such as seluang jalur emas, lias puteh, keli hutan and keli limbat as well as marine fish such as the telakai (short fin eel), ikan lelauh minyak (seven finger threadfin) and terubuk bengkalis can no longer be found in local rivers and seas,” he said.

Dr Mohd Azmi called for better marine management, saying that at the rate the seas and rivers were being abused, Malaysians might not be able to find their favourite fish on their dinner tables in just a few years

Koh agreed that some fish had become rare and were no longer seen.

“An example is the lai liew har (mantis prawn). A decade ago, it was considered an inferior type of seafood and nobody bought them.

“Now, they are highly sought after. Unfortunately, they are difficult to catch because they are hard to find at sea,” he said.

Former fisherman Ng Hwa, 54, said the mudflats in and around Kampung Sasaran smelled bad because they were strewn with rotting rubbish.

Like Koh, he blamed the discharge of waste from factories upstream.

“Plastic is the worst. You throw them into the sea and they remain there for a hundred years,” he said.

He said pollution caused the number of fish such as belanak (mullet) and tau tai (pomfret) and sai tou (wolf herring or ikan parang in Malay) to dwindle.

Another article taken from same paper.

Many popular fish species fast disappearing

KUALA LUMPUR: Your favourite fish may not be on your dining table in 10 years. Fish are becoming harder to catch and getting smaller in size.

Local freshwater and marine fish expert Prof Mohd Azmi Ambak said the depletion of some marine species was worrying.

“Land reclamation, silting, deforestation, water pollution and the disappearance of the mangrove swamps has disrupted the fish food chain and breeding patterns of some of the species.

“Global warming, the changing currents and tide patterns have also affected the marine eco-system, resulting in some species disappearing or becoming harder to find,” said Dr Mohd Azmi, a senior lecturer at Universiti Malaysia Terengganu’s Fisheries and Aquaculture Department.

He said too much fishing and poor enforcement on the use of nets had also caused many common marine species to dwindle in population.

“There is a need to act quickly to save and protect the species from total extinction. There is also a need to educate the public, including fishermen,” he said.

He said species like the short fin eel (telakai), seven finger threadfin (ikan lelauh minyak) and terubuk bengkalis spawned in the mangroves.

“With mangrove swamps being destroyed for wood or reclaimed for development, these species have disappeared,” he said.

In Penang, Fishermen Association (southern district) chairman Arshad Omar claimed that humans were responsible for the depletion of many kinds of fish.

“Trawlers are fishing wantonly. Their activities pollute the seabed, making the water murky, destroying the corals and reducing fish and prawn populations.”

The human factor, he said, was worse than the pollution factor. People are literally eating fish into extinction.

A fishmonger in Bayan Lepas, known as Ah Lim, said he had to source fish from other northern states to meet demand in Penang.

He said they could not let their customers down, especially during the festive season, when some were willing to pay RM45 per kilo for certain species.”

PC,
To be fair, the article appeared after PeMM’s opinion on the matter was published through our letter to the editor in reaction to the Fisheries Dept. DG’s comment that inshore fishing is being depleted.
Here’s a copy of our letter that appeared in the Star as well as NST.

Fisheries Department DG Datuk Junaidi Che Ayuh is not wrong in saying that there is a worrying trend of overfishing in Malaysian waters. His reported reason for this statement is due to overfishing by the coastal fishermen, namely the nelayan.
As such, he proposes that the nelayan either fish in deeper waters or upgrade to aquaculture.
In our opinion, the Fisheries Department should look at the bigger picture of Depletion of marine resources rather then focusing on overfishing alone which itself is a contributing factor to the depletion.
Globally, there have been countless studies on this problem and the main reasons are as follows:

a. Destruction of habitat
b. Pollution
c. Climate changes
d. Use of unauthorized methods and nets
e. Greed
f. Lack of enforcement

Destruction of habitat

Inn clearing of mangrove forest in the name of development and business, we are destroying the habitats of most fish as it is within the mangroves that they lay their eggs, mature and spawn.
Trawler boat encroachment into coastal areas also destroy the coral beds which are also fish habitats. Corals that took several hundred years to form are destroyed when the heavy metal plates of the trawler nets are dragged across the coral beds.
Siltation and sand mining causes formation of unnatural sand banks that prevents the migration of fishes to their regular breeding grounds.

Pollution

Pollution is not confined to illegal dumping of toxic waste but also the household and industrial chemical we release into our drains. Such chemical makes its way to the oceans killing off wetlands, mangroves and coral beds; all of which are fish habitats and spawning grounds.
Chemicals are also responsible to the change in the reproductive cycle of marine life.
Oil spills at sea or the scheduled desludging of oil tankers causes oil slicks that makes it way to our shores as well. Such slicks are usually undetected unless there are major oil spills. By the time they are detected, all life within its path would have been negatively affected one way or another.

Climate changes

Global warming has indeed changed the climates of the world. Monsoon seasons which were predictable in Malaysia are now no longer so.
Climate changes have also encourage such phenomenon as La Nina, El Nino,
red tides, etc.

Use of unauthorized methods and nets

The use of the many types of unauthorised trawler nets not only destroys fish habitats buts literally sweeps the ocean clean within its path. Sharks, rays, dolphins, billfishes, etc which have little or no commercial value are caught in these nets.
The use of explosives in fishing also causes destruction of fish habitats. Fish species not targeted for harvest remains collateral damage thus depleting chances of restocking.
Unregulated net mesh sizes contribute to the harvest of juvenile and baby fishes which are then sold as trash fish for the aquaculture businesses.
Long lining also contributes to depletion as these fishing lines runs for miles within migration routes. There is no guarantee that the targeted species remains the only species on the line.

Greed

Without regulations on seasonal fishing, catch limits, etc. the fisherman would
be acquiring bigger and better fishing vessels equipped with sophisticated gadgets to improve their catches. A good example is the use of spotter planes and helicopters to locate Tuna schools for harvest by one vessel and another refrigerated vessel for storage.
Encroachment by foreign fishing vessels in our waters must be severely dealt with. They must be made an example of to deter future encroachment by other fishing vessels.
The demand in quality fish for the table has also increased its value; thus encouraging the use of unethical methods of harvest to meet the demands.

Lack of enforcement

Too many times have we witnessed trawler boats trawling within 5 nautical miles of an island or coral bed. To date, we have yet to hear of any action taken on such vessels.
There is a regulation on net mesh size yet the trawlers are employing nets with much smaller net mesh sizes. This is an open secret. There should be more stringent surprise inspections on fishing vessels while at sea. Those caught flouting this regulation should have its vessel confiscated and its operating licence revoked.
Net mesh sizes should be enforced across the board from the nelayan to the trawler boats.
Possibility of a total ban on trawling boats. Considering the destruction caused by the trawler boats and its operators refusal to adhere to regulations, it would be better off to just ban them. The Fisheries Department can then encourage them to enter the aquaculture industry as they have proposed to the inshore nelayan.
The number of commercial fishing licenses should be limited and restricted to the licence holder. Upon his death, the operating licence is deemed expired.
Renewal of licences is subject to review by the Fisheries Department.
Seasonal fishing, catch limits, exclusive non-fishing zones must be introduced and enforced. This would increase the survivability of fish stock in our waters.
The Government must realize that in the name of development, we have sacrificed on the environment. We cannot be only exploiting it and not give back to Nature. Our marine resources are limited and therefore must be protected and encouraged.

This can be done through the following:

Construction and continual maintenance of artificial reefs at suitable areas.
Proper management and propagation of mangrove areas.
The gazette of exclusive no fishing zones.
Regulation and enforcement of seasonal fishing and catch limits to encourage restocking.
Strict and regular enforcement of fishing regulations by Fisheries Depatment and other authorities.

These are just a few facts that we realize through the use of common sense and observation. There are plenty of available hardcore scientific facts that can be referred to if further data is required.

There is no point of continual debate on the matter if there is no commitment on the necessary action to be taken to arrest the problem.
Let us all hope that we will see some positive changes in the governance of our natural resources in the near future.

Afterall, it is part of our heritage we leave behind for the future generation!

Richard Chuan
Public Relations and Multimedia
Persatuan Memancing Malaysia
</font id=“Times New Roman”></font id=“size3”></font id=“size4”></font id=“size5”>

RainbowRunner

Tightlines and screaming reels

Here’s another letter from our MFN forummer Doc Syed which appeared in the Star papaers yesterday.

Greedy trawlers equally to blame</font id=“size5”>

YES, the fishes are going away. The fishermen know this and attribute the reason for this to the poisoning by factories with the effluents they discharge into the rivers. (Where have the fishes gone?Sunday Star, June3).

I have been fishing as a hobby since 1974 in all the areas mentioned in the articles and also in areas not highlighted. Yes, I have noticed the catch dwindling all these years but the catch also is bad in areas where there are no rivers discharging into the locality.

The fishermen are quick to point the finger at factories but they are the biggest culprits. I have seen “Pukat Harimau” trawlers “dredging” the sea for all life forms. They go all the way right to the shore; they go all the way to the rims of islands designated as no commercial fishing areas.

They are not bothered about the laws, just intent to catch anything even “rubbish fish” as long as they can make money.

These trawlers can be seen pulling their nets right into the rivers leading to the dock. Just take a look at Port Klang along all the “selats” and riversides, it is happening very openly.

Pulau Angsa, a designated marine park is “dredged” regularly by the hour. Pulau Sembilan in Perak faces the same situation and these fishermen only stop when the fisheries or maritime enforcement unit is in the area. The fishermen claim, when asked by these officers that they are only parking there to rest.

In Pulau Aur, Johor, they boldly trawl within 50 meters of the islands, when the law states that the area’s five nautical miles from the islands are a designated marine estuary. The damage to the corals there is evidence of their intrusions.

The article also states the new crave for Mantis Prawn. Today these trawlers will dredge the bottoms of seas to hunt down this new “exotic”, and in the process destroy the breeding grounds and sea bed structure, necessary to replenish the species.

Once when I was fishing in Langkawi, I observed a huge tanker pulling a mega scale “Pukat Harimau” to dredge “ikan sampah” and anything else possible to process on-board into fertilizer. The trawler is normally “parked” along the 99 islands in the morning and will carry out their destruction at night.

These fishermen are armed with technology that will make them immune from persecution by the enforcers; they have long-range radios that will warn them if enforcement officers move out to sea.

Yes, the fishes are disappearing, and will be extinct soon. There is just not enough done to stop these people.

DOCSN,
Shah Alam.
</font id=“size2”>

RainbowRunner

Tightlines and screaming reels

Thks RR and Doc Syed for your contributions! Well done! Guess everyone just have to contribute our part, causing ripples here and there hopefully develop into tidal wave, big enough to rock the boat and catch the attention of the gomen to seriously take action to ensure sustainable fish source for yrs to come. As for general public and anglers, everyone just need to carry own responsible to stop littering around on the land as well as into the ocean. During recent visit to Redang noticed plenty of rubbish laying on the beach as well as on the coral bed. Have to literally be partime underwater perbandaran to pick up the trash and dispose them into the bins on the land. Indeed uphill battle for all concerned till the day we see light at the end of the tunnel.

PC, Just read latest Pancing mag. In it there was an article with photographs showing a trawler blatantly trawling in a RIVER!!! Someone should report this now that there is real evident. The very home and nursery to countless type of marine life swept away just like that. They are also killing themselves by destroying their future resource.

Hi Sthang,

DocSyed reported the same. Nowadays they are trawling nearer to the shore. These guys are getting desperate probably due to miserable catch offshore so now even inshore juvenile fishes also have been included in their list. Refer to The Star paper dated 22 January 2007:-

http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2007/1/22/nation/16642029&sec=nation

Inshore fishermen call for trawler ban

PENANG: For more than a year, inshore fishermen have been hard hit by the exploits of modified trawlers, which have jeopardised their livelihood.

The state fishermen association (southern district) chairman Arshad Omar yesterday presented a memorandum to Deputy Agriculture and Agro-Based Industry Minister Datuk Mah Siew Keong urging the government to ban modified trawlers.

Arshad said fishermen who used to earn between RM300 and RM400 a day were now barely earning RM100 even though they were out at sea till late evening.

He said the association, which has some 4,000 members, had approached the state fisheries department but they were told that there was no law to ban such trawlers.

What can we normal civilians do except making some noise here and there?!

I have been involved, volunteered, in drafting standards and laws for govt agencies and a ministry, It takes years to have a law amendment gazetted, mostly due to the many stakeholders involved. If we dont start now the battle would be lost. Rules and regulations are easier to put in place and we should look into that. Its always easier for a dept head to say there are no provision in the law to act on but sometimes they are empowered to come out with rules and regulations which are faster and is a good stop-gap measure.

The issues of deadly Pukat Harimau have been evolved even during the early 80’. Don’t have to be an angler to know the massive destruction of this method of harvesting, it was in the school textbook even kids knew. Everyone is aware no need to mention about the ministries assuming their are the experts. What lacking is the tidak apa attitude of the top guns.

Basically now we need collection of photos, articles in the papers, reports and complaints etc, compile and submit to the various NGOs. I’ll try MNS since I’m a member. Since the issue has made headline in Star paper and National Geography, have to keep the ball rolling. Medias and public voice will be one of the way out. Will check out Pancing later.

If we can put a stop to unregulated netting and trapping of freshwater fishes, we might not even need to promote CNR. it’s over and unregulated harvesting and unregulated unsustainable development that’s contributing to the ongoing decline of freshwater fishes, not because people don’t practice CNR. that’s my take. no doubt and undisputedly, the awareness of CNR is one of the key to conservation of fishstock.

My fishing site @ http://fishingboy.multiply.com/